HOMCOM 837-142 and the three-compartment IKEA BISSA both hide shoes behind flip fronts, but they spend the hallway's space differently. HOMCOM spreads across more wall and projects less into the walking route. BISSA uses less wall frontage and reaches farther into the room. That difference is more useful than a generic declaration that one cabinet is smaller. Compare the white HOMCOM and the exact white BISSA article linked here, then walk through the proposed location with each footprint marked.
The quick decision
Which would we choose?
HOMCOM is the stronger candidate beside a long, shallow walking route. BISSA is the stronger candidate between closely spaced doors or furniture where less wall width is available. Either choice still needs opening space and a suitable wall attachment; closed dimensions alone cannot establish the fit.
These selections compare manufacturer documentation, not hands-on testing. Confirm the exact version, dimensions, instructions, seller, availability, and returns. We cannot verify fit or durability in your home. Illustration photos show room ideas, not exact reviewed products. “Best” refers to the use cases within this shortlist, rather than a market-wide ranking. Research checked October 18, 2026.
Compare the models at a glance
Product dimensions exclude operating clearances. Dimensions are in inches; W = width, D = depth, H = height, L = length. Unlabeled brand dimensions are kept in their published order.
| Model | Size | Format | Best fit | Current offer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HOMCOM 837-142, white | 30 W × 7.5 D × 46 H in | Up to 12 pairs; maximum US men's size 10 | For a shallow closed cabinet | Search Amazon |
| IKEA BISSA 105.302.59 | 19¼ W × 11 D × 53⅛ H in | Three compartments; up to 12 pairs | For a short stretch of wall | Search Amazon |
Retailer links open a new tab. Search links are labeled “Search Amazon”; match the full model number. Check current price, availability, seller, and returns on the retailer page.
The shortlist
What each choice gives you
For a shallow closed cabinet
HOMCOM 837-142, white
30 W × 7.5 D × 46 H in · Up to 12 pairs; maximum US men's size 10
Three flip drawers conceal everyday shoes while keeping the closed cabinet shallow. This is a useful candidate when a hallway has enough wall width but little spare walking depth. The linked manufacturer listing describes the white 837-142 version.
Allow extra space to open each drawer and stand in front. Assembly and anti-toppling attachment are part of the setup. The stated shoe-size limit matters more than the pair count for larger footwear.
For a short stretch of wall
IKEA BISSA 105.302.59
19¼ W × 11 D × 53⅛ H in · Three compartments; up to 12 pairs
The three-compartment BISSA uses less wall width than the HOMCOM. Adjustable or removable dividers let you arrange the compartments around your collection, and a rear cutout accommodates a baseboard. IKEA's own listing is linked for specifications and direct shopping.
The narrower cabinet is deeper and taller. It must be fastened to the wall, and shoe shapes affect usable capacity. An Amazon search may include resellers or different versions; compare the exact article number with the IKEA page.
Compare the dimension that blocks the route
First identify the movement that fails today. If shoes already spill into a narrow passage, preserving floor depth should carry more weight than saving wall width. If the only free wall sits between a door frame and a radiator, a narrower cabinet may be the practical starting point. Mark both rectangles and include anything projecting from the wall. Avoid choosing by footprint area alone: two equal areas can create very different obstructions in a real hallway.
Test one drawer and one person together
Imagine using the middle compartment while wearing a coat and holding the pair you just removed. You need room to open it, stand, and move away again. The published closed depth does not describe that whole sequence, and the linked sources do not establish a complete open-drawer envelope for both cabinets. Check the exact drawing or ask the manufacturer for the missing measurement when it is critical. Do not invent clearance from a lifestyle photograph.
Make a shoe-by-shoe capacity plan
Choose the pairs that must go inside and group them by shape before comparing the headline capacity. BISSA's movable or removable dividers provide arrangement options, while HOMCOM explicitly identifies its maximum shoe size. Neither fact guarantees that a collection of ankle boots and chunky trainers will fill every compartment efficiently. If one difficult pair determines the purchase, confirm that pair's fit directly rather than assuming a twelve-pair label answers the question. Reserve another location for unsuitable footwear.
Compare the installed purchase
Include assembly, compatible wall fasteners, delivery access, and return arrangements in the decision. The shallowest closed cabinet offers little benefit if you cannot install it correctly on the available wall. Compare the seller's exact model with the official page, particularly for an IKEA reseller or a differently colored HOMCOM listing. A lower advertised price is not automatically the lower total cost if missing parts, unsuitable fittings, or a difficult furniture return become part of the job.
Before you choose
Common questions
Which cabinet takes less hallway depth?
The documented white HOMCOM is 7.5 inches deep when closed; the BISSA is 11 inches deep. Those exterior figures do not include an open compartment or the person using it. Use them to draw the first outline, then verify the full operating position.
Which uses less wall width?
BISSA is 19¼ inches wide compared with HOMCOM's 30 inches. BISSA is also taller, so check switches, hooks, and other wall features above the floor outline. Width, depth, and height should be evaluated together rather than collapsed into a single 'smallest' label.
Can either cabinet simply stand loose?
Plan to follow the wall-attachment instructions. IKEA requires BISSA to be fastened to the wall, and HOMCOM provides an anti-toppling design. Confirm the appropriate fittings for your wall before assembly instead of treating the cabinet's shallow depth as proof that it can stand unsecured.
Sources and how we chose
We compared the exact models below using their brand specifications and setup information. Recommendations reflect our interpretation of those documents for small-space use. They do not represent hands-on testing, customer ratings, or a measured performance ranking.
- HOMCOM 837-142, white: manufacturer specifications and support
- IKEA BISSA 105.302.59: manufacturer specifications and support
We omit live prices because offers change. No star ratings or review scores have been assigned. Read our full methodology.
Make the shortlist fit your room.
Measure the usable space, then add doors, drawers, hoses, and ventilation from the exact manual.
Open the fit check →